If you asked five people at a dinner party what your company does, you’d probably get five different answers.
The same thing could be happening online right now. AI engines run many searches and read dozens of pages to answer a single question. If those pages describe your company in conflicting ways, like dinner guests each giving a different answer, you become harder to name with confidence, and a rival with a clearer, more consistent story has the advantage.
Consensus Optimization is how you get those sources to agree, and how you make sure they describe you in a way that earns a positive recommendation.
If you’re reading this as a founder or marketing lead, then your brand signal is likely fragmented, and you’re seeing some of these problems:
- Competitors appearing ahead of you in AI answers to questions you should own
- AI answers that name you but describe you as expensive, unproven, or outdated
- Your site ranking well on Google, but your AI search visibility being extremely low
- Old press releases, social profiles, and review sites all describing you differently
Below, we break down how Mint Position built this framework while working with fintech, CRE financing, and B2B SaaS clients, and the results it has delivered.
We’ll also explain how you can use it to start improving your consensus in the eyes of AI search.
We’ll cover:
- Why AI engines don’t just read your website
- What your brand looks like and how fragmentation costs you AI citations
- The three pillars of Consensus Optimization
- How Consensus Optimization fits with GEO and SEO
- Consensus Optimization looks like in practice
- Start building your own consensus with Mint Position
Want the latest in AI search insights in your inbox every month? Sign up for our monthly newsletter and join our growing community of 2,000+ marketers and business leaders.
Why AI engines don’t just read your website
AI engines gather their information differently from the search engines of old.
In the past, search engines would rank individual pages and leave you to click through and piece together the answer yourself.
Now, if you ask an LLM like ChatGPT for the best investment app, for example, it won’t simply pull up one page. It runs a process called query fan-out, which splits your question into a cluster of related searches, then synthesizes the results into a single answer.
The key is to get these sources to agree on what your brand stands for so you can influence the answer LLMs give. This is what we call Consensus Optimization, and the first step is understanding which sources these are.
Where does AI draw its sources from?
In its 2026 AI citation study, OtterlyAI, an AI search visibility tracking platform, analyzed 617,985 citations across seven AI engines and broke down who publishes the pages AI cites.
Share of AI Citations By Publisher Type

Source: OtterlyAI
As you can see, brand-owned pages are the largest single group, but they only account for under 40% of citations. This share is split across every brand in your category.
The other 60%-plus? This comes from publishers, editorial sites, and communities, and your competitors may already be showing up there.
“From my experience, AI visibility is split between what lives on your own site and what the rest of the web says about you,” says Eric Turney, owner and sales and marketing director at The Monterey Company. “Third-party mentions matter a lot, including media quotes, Reddit discussions, review sites, YouTube, customer references, and industry pages, because AI systems look for outside confirmation that a brand is real and trusted.”

One more thing to note: These figures are averages across seven engines, and the engines differ sharply. For example, in January 2026, Reddit made up 24% of Perplexity’s citations but just 0.1% of Gemini’s, according to Tinuiti’s AI Citation Trends Report.
That gap shows us an important nuance: your team will eventually need to work engine by engine, finding which sources need the most work on the LLMs that matter most to your business, or that are underperforming.
This is the fundamental transformation we’re witnessing following the days of traditional search. Google ranks individual pages, but AI weighs how much its sources agree, and this is one of the main lines dividing GEO vs. SEO.
What your brand looks like and how fragmentation costs you AI citations
AI rewards brands it can describe consistently and favorably, so disagreement naturally holds your brand back. This is called brand fragmentation, and it often starts with your own messaging.
As your business grows, different people (you, your sales team, your marketing agency) might describe your business in different ways, according to what it offered when they wrote about it.
Let’s take the hypothetical example of a growing project management software company.
When it started five years ago, it described itself as “task management for small teams,” which is still on its G2 profile. It released a press release shortly after about a feature it has since retired.
Now, after growing into a larger company, it’s evolved into an AI workflow platform. Its marketing team looked into launching a new GEO strategy purpose-built for enterprise brands and rewrote the homepage and product pages to become more AI-visible, but nobody went back to update the G2 profile or publish a new press release.
An AI engine looking for the best project management tools isn’t getting a clear picture of what the business does because it has several different answers to choose from. The stale G2 profile also leads AI to describe it as a basic tool for small teams, a label that undersells the product today.

When this happens, AI tends to fall back on a competitor it can more easily verify. This is the problem Consensus Optimization solves.
Brand sentiment: Consensus Optimization isn’t just about where you’re mentioned, but how
The rush to get cited by AI engines has led many marketers to overlook one crucial thing: how these engines describe your brand. After all, they summarize what sources say about you and pass this tone onto your target buyers.
If most sources describe you accurately and favorably, that’s the story AI tells. Yet it’s also very easy for AI to repeat an old review that calls your pricing confusing or out-of-date product information – even after you’ve fixed both issues.
Many of these negative claims also come from places you can’t directly control. Peec AI’s analysis of 30 million US sources found Reddit was the first or second most cited domain on ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, and AI Overviews, for example. In this case, influencing updated answers on Reddit requires marketing finesse, and perhaps a good client to leave a strong impression via an ‘organic-sounding’ review.
Placement is also key. In a separate Peec study of nearly 200,000 AI responses, brands that rank first in frequently cited third-party listicles tended to appear earlier in AI answers, although Peec stresses this is an association rather than proof of cause.
Consensus Optimization, then, aims for positive agreement, instead of just agreement. You can’t fake this, but instead look at what buyers are complaining about and make sure you fix it. Some objections point to a real product gap. Many point to a content gap: if AI says you hide your fees, the cause is often a vague or missing pricing page.
The key is to track sentiment separately from visibility. Ask AI engines about your pricing, support, and legitimacy every month, because a brand can gain mentions while the tone of those mentions gets worse.
Building a positive consensus with AI will require you to monitor both visibilty and sentiment.
Take our software company example above. It may have G2 reviews praising it as a simple task tool, but others pointing out missing integrations it has since built. Ask AI about it, and the answer may describe a “basic tool for small teams.” This was once accurate, but now it’s unflattering and could hurt their reputation. The visibility and brand descriptors must be fixed by content strategies that tackle on-brand and off-site domains.
Only then can you build an accurate story of your brand that every source repeats. Each pillar below plays a part in that.
The 3 pillars of Consensus Optimization
Consensus Optimization is built on three pillars; each matches a group of sources that AI draws from.
We build these pillars in order because each one gives the next one something to point back to.

Pillar 1: Own your domain signal
Like a company style guide, your website is the benchmark for what every source should agree with. It should provide consistent messaging, and your blog should be backed up by expert and verified sources that AI engines can trust and quote with confidence.
Your site is also where you set the positive tone. Make sure you clearly state your strengths on key pages and back these up with evidence. We often see companies hurt their AI sentiment by leaving product and pricing pages vague or missing, so that is a good place to start your audit.
AI will then have accurate, positive facts to repeat.
Mint Position’s Journalistic SEO approach has engineered this into our content marketing naturally for years, but now those named experts and structured formats that AI can easily extract from have become even more valuable. It’s no longer a “nice thing to have,” but mandatory. This goes double-fold for industries that fall under Your Money Your Life standards, such as the financial, legal, and healthcare sectors.
The format is also important. Listicles make up two-thirds of cited pages, according to OtterlyAI’s study. These are mostly the “best X” articles that AI pulls from when buyers ask it to compare the best options.
Your content also has to be comprehensive and formatted in a way that AI can easily parse.
“Your own domain has to establish the facts first, clearly and structurally,” says Stephen Taormino, founder and CEO of CC&A Strategic Media. “Think FAQ formats, defined service descriptions, and direct answers to decision-stage questions. Third-party mentions then validate those facts. Neither works well without the other.”

Action for the software company example to take: Create a key article that ranks the best products in your field and mentions your brand in a positive light. The software company we mentioned above, for example, might publish a ranked guide to the best project management tools, with their head of product explaining the criteria through a detailed methodology. This gives AI a ready, citable, authoritative source.
Pillar 2: Earn third-party citations
Commission-earning publishers and editorial sites made up nearly half of the citations in the study, and the second pillar helps you show up there. You can earn these citations through press releases on high-authority domains and guest posts in industry publications.
Wikipedia is another earned source worth considering, though it sits outside these publisher groups, and it’s only possible if your brand meets their notability standards. If Wikipedia already mentions or lists your brand, you can request corrections to the page through editor channels.
Think of brand citations in the AI era as the new link building. If you can get your brand onto the domains that AI engines trust, then you’ll give them independent confirmation of what your own site says, which makes your brand far easier to recommend.
Placement alone isn’t enough, though. A roundup that ranks you last for customer support will cite you but not help recommend you. Aim for coverage that describes your strengths accurately and positively.
Action for the software company example to take: Start by updating the G2 profile to match the new “AI workflow platform” pivot, then pitch a guest post to a major tech publication. This post should include original data from the head of product.
Pillar 3: Build community signals
Reddit threads, LinkedIn posts, YouTube videos, and podcast transcripts are where buyers compare notes, and AI reads them too.
The type of engine comes into play here. According to the OtterlyAI study, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode get around a quarter of their citations from forums and video, compared with under 3% on other engines.
Community is also where sentiment forms fastest. An unanswered complaint thread can determine how AI describes you, so respond to criticism openly, aim to resolve the issue, and point to what’s changed when relevant.
Action for the software company to take: Have a member of staff answer questions in subreddits like r/projectmanagement and r/SaaS and share practical workflow tips on LinkedIn. YouTube walkthroughs with transcripts are also powerful proof.
Each should describe the product the same way its site now does, as an AI workflow platform. The key is to help rather than promote, because communities quickly downgrade anything that reads like an ad.
Note: Consensus is just the starting point as each engine weighs sources differently. In Peec’s data, Wikipedia leads ChatGPT’s citations, YouTube leads Google’s AI surfaces, and Reddit leads Gemini and Perplexity.
Once your story is consistent, you should weight the pillars toward the engines your buyers use to get the best results.
How Consensus Optimization fits with GEO and SEO
When ChatGPT launched in late 2022 and generative AI began making global waves, many search experts framed it as a battle between the old world of SEO and the new frontier of GEO (generative engine optimization).
But at Mint Position, we quickly realized that GEO wasn’t replacing SEO at all. Our clients at the top of Google’s results already had well-optimized profiles, and they were better placed to win in AI search once we optimized their content for it.
SEO makes you rankable. GEO is the goal: being cited and recommended by AI. Consensus Optimization is how we get there. It adds the element most GEO work misses: getting top sources to agree on who you are and to speak well of you.
Most GEO work stops at your own content. AI needs to see that your content is credible, but it also checks whether everyone else agrees, and whether they think you’re worth choosing. Consensus Optimization aligns every source AI reads and manages what those sources say about you.
It also reaches past GEO. The owned-domain pillar, along with review and PR work, helps your Google rankings too.
If you’re a brand already investing in SEO and GEO, there’s no reason to start over. Your rankings and AI-ready content already do the heavy lifting, but Consensus Optimization is the framework that makes sure every other source backs them up.
What Consensus Optimization looks like in practice
A framework is only as good as its results. Here’s how three financial brands, a UAE-based financial platform, a real estate funding start-up, and a challenger to South Africa’s biggest banks, put Consensus Optimization to work.
Sarwa: Named #1 in 43% of AI answers
UAE-based wealth platform Sarwa built its content strategy with Mint Position to outrank competitors on both Google and AI search. Since Peec tracking began in July 2025, the share of tracked AI answers mentioning Sarwa has risen from 32% to 79%, with the share naming it as the first brand climbing from 11% to 43%.

The gains hold across engines. Sarwa is now named first in 49% of Google AI Overviews answers, 48% on Gemini, and 47% on Google AI Mode.

Sarwa had an established brand to build on, which helped them to quickly gain AI traction, yet it’s also possible to start with almost no content authority at all.
This visibility has had a direct impact on lead generation.
In Q3 2026, Sarwa saw a record 3,492 new signups from AI platforms (according to Metabase data), making AI responsible for 12% of total signups that period – the highest share on record – adding a significant new leads pipeline that didn’t exist the year before.
Lula: ahead of South Africa’s biggest banks
South African SME funder Lula has some formidable rivals in their market and must compete with them on a fraction of the marketing budget. Working with Mint Position, they now appear in 59.5% of LLM results in their category, ahead of Standard Bank (54.1%) and FNB (51.7%).
Over the same quarter, organic leads rose 26.2% while total leads fell 11.8%, lifting organic’s share of leads from 13.35% to 19.1%.
“The shift is from winning the click to winning the recommendation,” says Umna Fredericks-Adams, Lula’s Head of Marketing.
Both brands made sure every source AI reads told the same story, and that’s a process any company can start.
Duckfund: From zero content authority to a 79% AI share of voice
Duckfund, a CRE soft deposit financing platform, started out with no content authority in its niche, but it partnered with Mint Position early on to build an expert-led, high-ranking domain. We extended this authority into listicles, a high-authority media placement, and an active presence in Reddit’s CRE investor communities once AI search became an imperative in 2025.
By August 2026, they held a 79% share of voice on ChatGPT and 59% visibility on Gemini, up from just 12% LLM visibility a year earlier. Over the same period, AI search registrations tripled, and one ChatGPT recommendation led to a $500,000 deal – the highest on record at that time.
“Even for investors without an immediate need, Duckfund stays top of mind and becomes the solution they turn to when that need arises,” says founder Anna Kogan.
Start building positive AI consensus with Mint Position
If you’d like to earn similar results for your brand, you won’t get them overnight, but you can start by building a GEO strategy that gets every source AI reads telling the same story about you.
At Mint Position, we can help you get off the ground with a GEO audit that uncovers exactly what AI is saying about your brand right now, and the gaps you need to fill.
The audit will identify your weakest pillar, whether it is your owned content, third-party mentions, community presence, or the way AI describes you that is letting your story down.
From there, you can start building your consensus, with your own domain as the bedrock. Brand-owned pages are still the largest single source that AI engines draw from, and your other pillars will point back to them.
Remember that dinner party? You can’t control every conversation, but you can make sure every guest leaves with the same story.
Consensus Optimization helps AI engines cite and recommend your brand by making your story consistent and favorable across the web. Book a no-cost consultation with the Mint Position team, and we’ll show you how our approach can win you customers in the AI era.


